Heavy metals in Athabasca River comparable to levels in bottled water

The Department of Renewable Resources' William Shotyk, the Bocock Chair in Agriculture and the Environment, gives a tour of the new $4.7 million ultra-clean lab.
Preliminary results from an ALES study of the Athabasca River shows levels of heavy metal comparable to bottled water and some of the remotest bodies of water in Algonquin Park.

World-renowned soil and water scientist William Shotyk and his research team sampled water from 12 locations along a 125-km stretch of the Athabasca River starting at Fort McMurray and heading downstream. The team analyzed the water, looking for heavy metal contamination. They then compared their results to other studies they had done in Coldspring Lake, the most remote lake in the 7,600-square kilometre Algonquin Park, and with the Nipissing River, where it travels across Algonquin Park.

Shotyk and his team found that the Athabasca River water averaged 25 parts per trillion (PPT) of lead, compared to 40 PPT in Coldspring Lake and 180 PPT in the Nipissing River. The amount of lead in the Athabasca River also compares comfortably with bottled water.

“Many brands of bottled water have as much lead or more than what is found in the Athabasca River,” said Shotyk, who conducted an exhaustive study of heavy metal contaminants in bottled water in the mid-2000s when he examined 132 brands from 28 countries. Bottled waters in glass typically contain five to 10 times more lead than the scientists found in the Athabasca River.

Shotyk added that the Athabasca contains 50 PPT of antimony compared to 30 PPT in the Coldspring Lake.

“It’s well within the range,” said Shotyk, who is also the Bocock Chair in Agriculture and Environment. Bottled water in plastic typically contain 10 to 20 times more antimony than the scientists found in Athabasca Rover. Shotyk said the values he published earlier for heavy metals in bottled water help to put the data from the Athabasca River into perspective.

The findings are entirely consistent with Shotyk’s previous results obtained from examining sphagnum moss from 21 different peat bogs around the oil sands area, near open pit mines and processing facilities. In that study, which was published in Environmental Science and Technology, Shotyk found that atmospheric lead pollution is insignificant, with lead concentrations far lower than those found in surface layers of peat cores collected in recent years from bogs ranging from British Columbia to New Brunswick.

Shotyk announced his latest findings during the official opening of the $4.7 million SWAMP Lab, a state-of-the-art ultra-clean lab in which almost everything is made of plastic in order to avoid contamination by metals.

The lab is equipped with precision instrumentation, including two mass spectrometers that can detect trace metals down to parts per trillion, and parts per quadrillion. One part per quadrillion is comparable to one single raindrop in the volume of Lake Huron, one of the five Great Lakes of North America. Next month, when the lab takes delivery of Flow Field Flow Fractionation instrumentation, it will be the only lab in western Canada and one of only two in Canada able to measure heavy metals in aquatic nanoparticles, which are 1,000 times smaller than the width of a human hair.

Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development and the University of Alberta funded the construction of the lab while the Canada Foundation for Innovation, Alberta Innovation and Advanced Education, and the University of Alberta’s Faculty of Agricultural, Life & Environmental Sciences each contributed to purchasing the equipment for the lab.

Shotyk is seizing the opportunity provided by the lab and its equipment to take a fresh look at heavy metal pollution in the area with a view to determining what is occurring naturally and what is occurring as part of the industrial activity of the oil sands.

His next step with the water study is to collect and analyze a similar number of water samples along the same stretch of the Athabasca River next spring and summer and compared those results with the ones he obtained this year.

The research is being supported by Alberta Innovates – Energy and Environment Solutions and Canada’s Oil Sands Innovation Alliance.

In addition to his studies of air and water, Shotyk plans to look at cumulative impacts of dust and metals to plants and soil.